tonight i smoked a Macanudo Robust. the draw was very tight. the finish was short and low in flavor. i was very dissapointed. anyone who has smoked this cigar have an opinion?

That's why I call them Macadoodles. Very famous and very popular with the non-cigar smoking crowd, but extremely mild. If you enjoy a cigar that has a little body, the Mac is not for you.

I agree with doc. I had heard the name quite a bit, and never had one until a couple of months ago, and I was shocked at the lack of body.

I just assumed since I had heard the name and seen them in quite a few shops that it would be a pretty good smoke...I was wrong.