Should I buy a 25 box of Monte #4 and a 10 box of RyJ Short Churchills OR a 25 Box of Monte #4 and a 10 box of Partagas 8.9.8 OR a 25 Box of H. Upmann Mag 46??

Man these decisions are hard!

Aaron

This message has been edited. Last edited by: CUsccrstud21,

25 of Monte #4 and 10 of RyJ Short Churchills.

Just my 2 cents.

Jason

If it were me I'd do the Montes and the Mags...

my vote is for the Montes and the Mag's I am not a R&J short churchill fan for some reason Tasted weak to me. just my opinion. I cant say I have a lot of experience with the Partagas

just to make things worse, monte 4 and 898...

haha, well i just placed my order...i wish i coulda got both the Mags and Montes! I decided to spend a little less cash this time around and just got the 25 Box of Monte #4 and then 5 Trini Reyes....i haven't been able to acquire any Reyes until now so I wanted to make sure to get enough that I will be able to evaluate them properly...thanks for the input!

I had a similar problem lately between a box of Monte #4 and a random 5 pack or a box of Siglo 2s.

I went Siglos... my humidor smiled.

In that case, two boxes of Trini Reyes and no Montes!

haha, that's the problem tho, my source didn't have reyes by the box, only singles...otherwise i would've bought a box of each!

Well either way you got some good smokes. Let us know what you think of the Monte #4. I have never tried one, but hear good things. I went with Boli PC's instead.

I bought some san Cristobol petite coronas instead and like them better than the Montes and Bolivars that I am currently smoking. I guess it is just a matter of preference and palates.

Maybe consider trying the MC4 box and a 5 pack of the Robania Famosos, and three paks of both the Upmann Magnum 46s and also the Partagas Serie D no 4's. You'll be happy.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Dr. Wu,

bburnham17: wanna do a trade, some Monte 4s for some Boli PCs?

I love the monte 4s...i haven't had the chance to try the San Cristobal PCs though so looks like i'll go add those to my wishlist...

I already have a couple of PSD4s waiting patiently in my humi so that's why i didn't order some of those...i got about 7 business days till heaven! :-D

i would have a hard time passing up those h.upmanns,s myself.to each his own i always say.

i'll probably order them in about a month or so...and i need to start lookin for a cabinet humi, i've almost outgrown my 250 ct and 50 ct ones...let this be a lesson learned, i've only been collecting cigars since March! I started with 9 cigars in a 15ct humi and now in 4 months i've accumulated almost 300...damn i need to smoke faster!