About six months ago I got a box of Magicos and I'm so addicted. My question is, are the flavors across the line consistent? Would the genios be consistant with the magicos & the secretos? If so, my next purchase will be the big brother of the series. Thanks.
I bough a sample pack of 9 maduros (3x of all 3 sizes) and found the Magicos to be the best. The larger sizes are rather disapointing, and may need a few years to come around.
"Bud spelers of the word unight, and remumber: cabron is most abundent elemant in hte youknwverse"
Yeah, as we all know SHB is not too impartial about maduros 5
I have tried quite a few Secretos and just one Genio, but unfortunately no Magicos. Based on that - Secretos seemed a lot richer, with spicy and coffee flavors dominating. Awesome smoke. For Genios the flavors were not that pronounced, but still quite a good smoke. Though I guess with just one smoke it's not fair to judge, especially that at the time the person who gave it to me said it's just a month or two old.
------- "And it is not just a business. It’s a love affair." Paul B.K. Garmirian about making cigars
I have been very much enjoying the Genios. Very high quality cigar. I dunno Steve, these taste very good to me and I think that the ingredients are all there for these to age very well. To my pallete they taste great now...I managed to pick up a 25 count box for less than $400 and I am very happy i did.
quote:
Originally posted by Steve Cohen: Yea a 5 year old wrapper. I fear that this is as good as they get, and no amount of aging will help these cigars.
quote:
Originally posted by salibas007: from the 3 vitolas, I find the secretos to be the best tasting one, as of now...
I have a box of each that I have stashed for aging... we'll see how they'll compare to each others in 2 or 3 years....
what's funny, is that you'd think that such old tobacco would be eady to smoke now... ah well... think again
Posts: 234 | Location: NY, NY | Registered: May 08, 2002
Originally posted by Steve Cohen: I bough a sample pack of 9 maduros (3x of all 3 sizes) and found the Magicos to be the best. The larger sizes are rather disapointing, and may need a few years to come around.
Did you mean to say that you found the Secretos to be the best?
When the facts change, I change. What do you do, sir? - Lord Keynes
Posts: 2279 | Location: the GTA | Registered: November 28, 2007
Originally posted by Steve Cohen: Yea a 5 year old wrapper. I fear that this is as good as they get, and no amount of aging will help these cigars.
The wrapper is 5 years old, but what about the rest of the tobacco in the cigar?
I think people generally prefer the Secretos because you get more of the wrapper flavor with such a small diameter cigar, whereas with the larger sizes, the wrapper contributes much less to the overall flavor of the cigar. Based on that justification, I think the larger size Maduros will come around nicely in a couple of years, once the binder and filler "catch up".
When the facts change, I change. What do you do, sir? - Lord Keynes
Posts: 2279 | Location: the GTA | Registered: November 28, 2007
just got 10 of the secretos in todays mail,i'll put them away for a month and then try them out,seems from what i read they should be good,im a siglo 2 man usually..also got 10 monte petite edmundos,anybody have a feel for these,thanks
The Secretos are decent cigars, but I would not say they are a home-run. Still waiting to see what these are like given some time.
______________________________ It's stay away from Malaysia for fear of vampires year!
"The word Fascism has now no meaning except insofar as it signifies 'something not desirable'." -- George Orwell, "Politics and the English Language," 1946
High Post Count = Manliness and Importance
#2 Most Friendly Guy, Connoisseur of All Things Fine, Elitist Ass, and One of the Two Biggest Douchebags in the Forums
its unfair to compare the cohiba lines for taste, apples and well...different apples.
if you enjoy the magicos, you will love the genios. they are real gems. the secretos appear to be the most popular, but i have a small hunch that it more due to their vitola, availability and price point.
Originally posted by Don Andres: the secretos appear to be the most popular, but i have a small hunch that it more due to their vitola, availability and price point.
This crossed my mind as well, but it seems that most everyone who has smoked and can afford all three still feel that the Secretos are the best of the line.
When the facts change, I change. What do you do, sir? - Lord Keynes
Posts: 2279 | Location: the GTA | Registered: November 28, 2007
Originally posted by Don Andres: the secretos appear to be the most popular, but i have a small hunch that it more due to their vitola, availability and price point.
well i disagree on this one...
I have a box of each.. and when i tried them all, i found the secretos to be the one that is the most ready to be smoked as of right now...
Agreed. I had another Genios the other day and they are superb. Not had the smaller sizes yet but I get these Genios on sale for $16 per stick and I think they are definately worth it at that price.
quote:
Originally posted by Don Andres: i have a small hunch that it more due to their vitola, availability and price point.
cheers drew p
Posts: 234 | Location: NY, NY | Registered: May 08, 2002
Originally posted by Don Andres: the secretos appear to be the most popular, but i have a small hunch that it more due to their vitola, availability and price point.
well i disagree on this one...
I have a box of each.. and when i tried them all, i found the secretos to be the one that is the most ready to be smoked as of right now...
fair enough. perhaps the smaller vitola is coalesing faster than the larger vitola, but i stand by my statement.
after smoking the cohiba 06 pyramides el yesterday with friends, we wondered if perhaps this were the original inspiration for the maduro 5 line and were left hoping that some day the very fine genios would mature into puros comparable to the near perfect els.
So you think the 06 Piramide EL is that much better than the Genios??
[/QUOTE]
fair enough. perhaps the smaller vitola is coalesing faster than the larger vitola, but i stand by my statement.
after smoking the cohiba 06 pyramides el yesterday with friends, we wondered if perhaps this were the original inspiration for the maduro 5 line and were left hoping that some day the very fine genios would mature into puros comparable to the near perfect els.[/QUOTE]
Posts: 234 | Location: NY, NY | Registered: May 08, 2002
