Okay, so far I think this is the best full bodied cigar I've had. I was told to try out the Partagas Black Label, but it tasted pretty dirty and weak to me, could have just been that one, I'll give it another two tries (third time is a charm, so I generally will give things at least three chances).

Camacho Corojo was great, lots of flavor, great draw, and a very well put together cigar given its price. Although I'm still a novice and the most prestigous cigar I've had is a Padron 1964 Anniversary (thanks to Howma!), this cigar was fantastic, and delivered the powerful and robust flavor I've been searching for. I only wish I could find other cigars with this much flavor.

Camacho Corojo is a very good full bodied cigar. If you want a step up from that one, try the La Flor Dominicana Chisel

For some other options check out what everyone is smoking in the Daily Smoke thread.

I've already checked with my local shop here, and he doesn't have the La Flor Dominicana Chisel, so I guess I'm stuck with the Camacho Corojo. Thanks for the advice though!